Geriatric Superstar

Jesus Christ, Superstar starring Ted Neeley

So here I am, sitting on my couch, watching the Lord of the Rings trilogy on TNT (there’s a great way to lose a weekend, by the way), when I see an ad for a production of Jesus Christ, Superstar coming to the Warner Theater March 17-22. Having been a fan of this particular show since I was a kid (and it’s a popular choice for musical companies during Lent), I stopped to take notice… and saw that Ted Neeley is playing Jesus.

Okay, what the hell. Ted Neeley is the best-known Superstar Jesus. He played Jesus in the movie in his 20s, played him on Broadway, played him in the touring production for the movie’s 20th anniversary in the 90s, but people: Ted Neeley is 65 years old. For the record, that’s nearly twice as old as Jesus of Nazareth ever lived to be. I caught a performance on that tour in the 90s- he was sounding a little rough then, and that was 15 years ago. And look, no disrespect to Neeley- the lead roles in Superstar are vocally challenging even to performers in their prime. There’s a lot of high-pitched shrieking to be done, and it’s a strain.

Is there really no one else who can believably play this role that we’ve got to trot out a guy who is nearly as old as my grandfather to play someone about my age? Are audiences really so unwilling to see other people playing Jesus?

Comments

106 Responses to “Geriatric Superstar”

  1. Laurie Says:

    My response— UMMMM NOOOOO there is no one else who can play this role like TED!
    Aren’t you glad you asked! :)

  2. Tina Says:

    ask me again when your 65… if you could pull off what he does at 65 at your age ( what are you 20?) then maybe I could listen to your lack of consideration. But lets face it there aren’t many people who can hit those notes even at a young age, let alone at 65.. Not to mention he brings more then vocal talent to the role. Give the man the respect he’s due.

  3. Soraya Says:

    No, I would not watch the play if Ted was not playing Jesus. It’s just not the same without him.

  4. Tom Bridge Says:

    Neeley ought to retire and let someone else have a crack at the role.

    Or, they could do the right thing, and retire the musical in its entirety.

  5. Tiffany Bridge Says:

    Well, I hope you’d all be as insistent that age doesn’t matter if they were to cast Tyne Daly as Mary Magdalene. Oh, you wouldn’t? That’s a hell of an age-related double-standard you’ve got there.

  6. Don Says:

    Give up, Tiff. There’s a contingent of people determined never to change or be exposed to new music, plays, books, or talent.

    They’ll drop their $200 to go to the megaplex of suck so they can see The Who sing, without irony, how they hope they die before they get old… even while a ton of talented musicians play music they haven’t heard a million times before just down the road from them for 10% of the cost.

    And they’ll go see someone play a role they’re 40 years too old for, justifying supplanting someone age-appropriate with the fact that the performer still has the talent to pull off the role.

    Then next week they’ll bitch about how idiotic it is that Hollywood casts women in their late 30s to play the mothers of actors in their early 20s. And they’ll do it as free of irony as Mr Daltry.

  7. Shawn McKay Sanders Says:

    Don, Tiffany, et al.

    It does not matter the age, it only matters the conviction of which you play the role. Regardless of gender, age, etc., play it from your heart and the masses will respond. Faithfully they will respond through the decades. If someone younger wishes to play the role with that much conviction, we will embrace them as well. Please see the 1973 movie and talk with the man before commenting any more. Ted is very approachable.

  8. Tina Says:

    Im not saying no one else should play the role.. Im saying dont knock the man because he CAN!!!!

  9. Roz Says:

    Tyne Daly is a wonderful actress, and if she can sing, why not? I’d go see her in the role, you betcha.
    And FYI: Ted can sing the screaming high notes better than anyone. Yes, he’s older than the real Jesus in earth years, but the real Jesus is eternal, so does it really matter?

  10. Soraya Says:

    I can honestly say that I would not enjoy seeing Tyne Daly play Mary M., but I would be absolutely thrilled to see Yvonne Elliman in that part again. It’s got nothing to do with age, or the fact that he is a man. That is so ridiculous.

  11. Tiffany Bridge Says:

    It’s not at all ridiculous when you consider that, aside from a few superstars who aren’t afraid to invest in plastic surgery, female actress’ phones generally stop ringing once they’ve passed 40. Meanwhile, Emma Thompson is young enough to be Dustin Hoffman’s daughter, but he gets cast as her love interest, and the examples can go on and on. Sean Connery can be voted “Sexiest Man Alive” at 59, but at 42, Nicole Kidman has to ruin her face with a toxic substance used as a bioweapon to keep getting roles.

    It has everything to do with being a man- men are allowed to get old in show business and still play leading roles. Women are not.

  12. Tina Says:

    Just because a person is of a certain age doesnt mean they cant effectively play a role. I would go see a younger person playing an older role and visa versa if they could effectively play the role. But lets be honest here we were talking about Ted, and yes there have been others to tackle the role of Jesus in this rock opera and guess what….they all flopped… hey.. go figure a 65 year old could do it better… lets not worry about age and just be accepting of those who can take on a challenge and make it work.

  13. Shawn McKay Sanders Says:

    Helen Mirren? Oscar winner last year? Susan Lucci? Jane Seymour? Tina Turner? Dinah Ross?

  14. Tiffany Bridge Says:

    Helen Mirren won the Oscar for playing someone 10 years older than herself in the movie’s time period, so you’re proving my point. Susan Lucci is now appearing on “Dancing With the Has-Beens,” and Diana Ross is a punchline so sad that I’m surprised you’d even mention her in the same sentence as Tina Turner, who, by the way, now has to sing with young little things like Beyonce in order for it to be called a “comeback.”

  15. Shawn McKay Sanders Says:

    You, just proved my point.

  16. Tiffany Bridge Says:

    By pointing out how terrible your examples are? Dandy.

  17. Sonja Clark Says:

    I have seen this “new” production with Ted Neeley. Sad to say, he moves like he needs a walker and has no spunk at all, even during the temple scene. His voice cracks, he speaks half the lines that should be sung. He fumbles around on the stage holding onto his co-stars. The set is so bare bones that it is kinda sad. To see a production that was once wonderful diminished to this is sorry. They say the simple set is to highlight the message, well anyone who comes to this play already knows the message, they want to be entertained, not put to sleep, and the climax of the play, the crucifixion? Ted Neeley drags that out so long that you want to get up and leave. The best part of this play is the chorus, bright scarfs and very talented. Yep, Ted Neeley, be it a nice guy or not, should move to something more age related, maybe Moses????

  18. Shawn McKay Sanders Says:

    Final comment for the evening. I am a mother of four kids…16, 13, 7, and 5. I retired two years ago from 25 years of service from the Navy and Marine Corps, who was also deployed to Iraq in 2003. Our group was the forward deployed unit into the start of the war and shot at repeatedly. So, when I bring up examples of strong women, I speak from experience. Tina Turner and Diana Ross are a personal favorite of mine, who are the examples of strong women, who are not punch lines…but one I know of, were punching bags by the male in their life. But, they perserved. My “dandy” examples are not without merit. I still stand on the front lines in a different career in D.C., with a different agency and defending the homeland. So, twenty some year old, if you are looking for strong women examples, project yourself twenty years from now and ask, if you will be one of those examples.

  19. Claire North Says:

    The comment you made re: Ted Neeley portraying Jesus in JCSS is extremely ill-informed. I recently saw the show and Ted and cast were magnificent so the “geriatric” label is hurtful to the crowds who turn up to watch the show. Ted portrays his character with dignity, and with a youthfulness people half his age would envy. On top of the wonderful voice he still has, he is an unquestionably warm, approachable person. Maybe instead of sitting on your couch judging him, you should put a little more effort into your homework and contact him for an interview….yes he is older than Jesus but so what? I HAVE seen JCSS all over the world with different characters and actors and no-one had EVER come near to the conviction and emotional intensity that Ted Neeley brings to his portrayal. Try for one day to let only positive things come from your pen, and not venom. It is not clever, nor funny, but IS hurtful to many people. Is that how you see yourself? If so, then it is you that I pity.

  20. Tom Bridge Says:

    Shawn, while I appreciate your service to our nation in its defense, it has no bearing on the conversation at hand, and only serves to shelter you from legitimate criticism.

  21. Shawn McKay Sanders Says:

    Tom…no sheltering needed here. Relevance to conversation…please read the string of conversations above. Age, Strong Women, Ted Neeley, appreciation of those who have the conviction to take on the role and do well. Bottom line, as I mentioned above, go see the show, spend a bit of time talking with Ted after the show, look him in the eye, and then tell him of any criticisms you have of him and the show. If you do that, then you have bearing here.

  22. Tom Bridge Says:

    I think I’ll take Claire’s word for it that Ted might need a walker, Shawn.

  23. Sonja Clark Says:

    Shawn, I have met Ted Neeley after a show and I found him quite condescending and having a bit of a Jesus complex. He was nice enough but it all seemed programed and not very sincere. Sorry but to me he comes off as a phoney.

  24. Claire North Says:

    No, I did in no way say that Ted needed a walker….I do not make facious comments like that…..so please do not incorrectly misquote me….I enjoyed the show and infact am going again in a few weeks so that should inform you how I feel about this production. so there!!!

  25. Tom Bridge Says:

    Oop, sorry Claire, it was Sonja that said he needed a walker. My bad!

  26. Allyson Says:

    Dear Tiffany,

    Ted doesn’t need defending. Go to the show and see for yourself.
    The Who don’t need defending either. “Older” performers bring a history and a maturity to their performances. Someday you will understand that. Your flippancy will mellow down and you will be glad to see a legend. Maybe someday….
    Allyson

  27. Tiffany Bridge Says:

    I love how people keep making assumptions about our ages. Honestly, Shawn, your military service is irrelevant to the conversation, and the fact that some of the people you cite have been victims of domestic violence really just underscores the point I am making about women in showbiz- Tina Turner IS a legend. She’s amazing, and strong, and yet somehow she has to share the stage with Beyonce to get any time at the Grammys. That’s a disgrace. The question isn’t whether there are any legendary, strong women- of course there are- the question is whether they get any respect from an industry that’s a slave to youth. They don’t, generally.

    As for Ted Neeley- no one is saying he’s not talented, but as it happens, I HAVE seen him perform this role, both as a young man and when significantly older, and I HAVE seen a number of other actors play the role, and the truth is… it’s just a level of vocal acrobatics that are starting to get away from him. Just like professional athletes eventually can’t do the same feats they used to do, the same thing happens to vocalists- after all, your voice is still a function of your body.

    And what’s amusing to me is that none of you Neeley-partisans have mentioned that he only got the role to begin with, way back in his 20s, because the Jesus he was understudying for had to miss a show. So in essence, by continuing to sign on for this role that he’s been playing for longer than Jesus ever actually LIVED, he’s denying some other actor the same chance he himself got.

  28. Lianne Says:

    Let me get this straight. You people are coming to this girl’s weblog, essentially. It looks like this is mostly a place for someone to discuss and talk. Maybe I’m misunderstanding and this is honest-to-God reviews, but this post doesn’t sound like one. It sounds like someone mulling over something they saw, in a public place. Which is her right, amirite?

    It’s pretty pathetic, in my opinion, that a bunch of people are now flaming the author of this entry because she posted her opinion. You don’t have to agree. You don’t have to even like what she says, but what gives you the right to sit and tell her how to feel?

    I’ve seen JCS live. I saw it at the first leg of this new tour. You know what I think? I think that Ted Neeley is old. I’m not saying he’s not talented. I’m saying that watching a man who is almost twice the age that Jesus is supposed to be takes away from the experience. I also think all the people who say that they wouldn’t see the play without Ted in it should stop and re-evaluate: You’re not fans of the musical at all, you’re fans of him, and that’s groovy, but don’t presume to tell others how they’ll feel regarding the musical. I would see it again without Mr. Neeley, and do you know why? Because the musical is a good one, and he doesn’t make or break it – he’d the lead actor, but he’s not irreplaceable. Assuming he is, is just you kidding yourselves.

    That being said, all else aside this girl brings a valid point: Ted Neeley no longer looks the part. Imagine if someone made a movie about Dr Martin Luther King Jr and cast a white man in the lead role. You’d be doing some head scratching, too. So stop insulting her and her intelligence for having an opinion and grow up. Not everyone has to agree.

  29. Shawn McKay Sanders Says:

    Tiff…yawn.

  30. Tiffany Bridge Says:

    Oh, Shawn, your witty discourse surely does put me in my place! *swoon*

  31. Shawn McKay Sanders Says:

    Nevermind Tiff…just heard why you do these blogs.

  32. Shawn McKay Sanders Says:

    Nevermind Tiffany…just heard why you do these blogs.

  33. Claire North Says:

    I would just like something positive to be said and would you please consider the number of people who keep going back to see him over and over again…the man brings a sense of compassion to his role that you might want to emulate with your pen……….and as I earlier mentioned, I have seen the show numerous times without Ted in the lead role and none have ever touched me the way he does in his performance.
    He does not hog the role…he simply gets asked to do the show over and over again, he infact has other great works that are held up because of audience demand for him portraying Jesus.
    I am glad that you seem to be able to blithely sit back and make such negative comments, maybe one day when you grow up you will find that the kind of hurt you throw around does nothing to make this planet better….as I earlier said try to write something positive just once and see how it works out. It might even become a habit, positivity breeds positivity.

  34. Shawn McKay Sanders Says:

    Props Claire…keep the circle turning.

  35. Dee Says:

    Wow! I bet you didn’t know what you were getting into by calling Ted ‘geriatric’ now did you Tiffany? I have to wonder if you have gotten this much feedback from any other posts? Lianne hit the nail on the head when she said “You’re not fans of the musical at all, you’re fans of him”. Ted has a LEGION of fans that will defend his right to play Jesus to their dying day. I know because I was one of them. I have seen JCS more times than I can count and a few times Ted was not playing Jesus. I will say those times the show did not thrill me. I was there to see Ted. Plain and simple. Well, also Carl Anderson who was a totally amazing, loving, and gifted man and singer. I think at this point it would be best for you all to ‘agree to disagree’. Tiffany, when a person comes into your life that you feel as strongly about as these people do Ted, then maybe you will understand. You might actually think back on this and smile and say ‘ah, so that’s what those people meant!’. Or not. Either way, it takes quite a lot, or is almost impossible, to sway the opinion of a ‘Ted Head’. Take it from someone who knows.

  36. Nancy Chritensen Says:

    You don’t seem to be able to imagine the fan base that Mr. Neeley has. Nor what a wonderful job he does in teaching the message of the ONE he portrays. Good God I feel sorry for your youthfullness. Hopefully when you are older no one will make such harsh judgements on you, and be able to see what talents you possess.
    Nancy Christensen

  37. Tom Bridge Says:

    Nancy, I just hope that someone will tell me when I’m interfering with the careers of those who will come after me.

    Or if I decide to play a role that I’m 30 years too old for.

  38. Tina Says:

    You know Tom I wonder how you would feel if you were told that something you love to do and were good at was no longer an option and you had to quit just because a minor portion of a very major population decided that you were to old to do what you do best. And don’t try to tell me you would be fine with that.. no one would. My feelings are if you are capable of doing a job you should be allowed to do so. People worry about social security being over run and yet when people try to continue working they are told they are to old. Bravo to Mr. Neeley for continuing to be a contributing member of society and not adding to the burden of an already under budgeted and over worked social security system. And yes I realize he is not of that age yet but he is getting there. Keep in mind one day you will be his age and you will be told to step aside. And finally, I have yet to see even one show that hasn’t been sold out or nearly sold out for every performance. What does that say? Obviously that he is doing SOMETHING right.

  39. Tom Bridge Says:

    I think it’s entirely possible that with Mr. Neeley’s significant talent he could find a role that was more age appropriate.

  40. Tina Says:

    and he has and does.. but he was asked to do this role. He didnt beg for it, and in fact turned down another role in order to do it. And in case your interested there is another show called “Rasputin” that he will be following up this tour with. So come on give the man a break.. find someeone your own age to pick on. nuff said.

  41. Sonja Clark Says:

    Hey Tina, if all the shows are sold out, then why is the tour ending early due to “economic issues” and all the Canada dates canceled? And I read that on Ted’s own website neeleyontheroad.com and believe it or not it was posted by GOD HIMSELF to Ted’s guestbook.
    And Tiffany, if you think these people are delusional here, check out Ted’s guestbook, these people are more than delusional, they are down right brainwashed!

  42. Tina Says:

    can you read? I said sold out or nearly sold out and the cancellation of the Canadian shows has nothing to do with ECONOMIC issues it was scheduling.. and that came from the horses mouth. They are trying to reschedule for Jan. so get your facts straight. And yes I agree some of the fans are a bit overzealous. But Brainwashed come on….you are welcome to your opinion of the show, everyone is, but to then put down others for having a different opinion is self indulgent and rude, not to mention hypocritical. The first blog on this was done by someone who hadn’t even seen this run of the show. At least you seem to have seen it. And like I said you are completely entitled to your opinion, but please don’t reprimand others for having theirs.

  43. Tiffany Bridge Says:

    Tina, if you’re going to lecture other participants in this conversation about reprimanding others for having an opinion, then I’m going to have to ask YOU to stop reprimanding US for disagreeing with you, which you have been doing now since comment #2.

  44. Sonja Clark Says:

    Tina, first check post #3438 on the guestbook, GOD HIMSELF says the tour is being cut short due to economic reasons(could it be that the show is overpriced at 50 to 100 $$$ a ticket?) Second..it’s not the show that you all are delusional about, the show was “ok” it’s the delusions that Ted Neeley can bless you and perform miracles. Your idea that he really IS Jesus is scary to say the least. And after I talked with him last year, I’d say he has the same delusions, even blessing someone right in the line I was standing in. He is an actor, not a priest and definately NOT the son of GOD! The show is not blasphemous, HE is on his offstage antics! I even read a while back that some man was bringing his sick child to a show for Ted to heal. Give me a break!! But the man represents himself, even off stage, as being divine. This is just wrong! Talk about giving people false hope. Anyway, you go and enjoy the show and bow down to your false God, I am not the one who will have to answer to the REAL God, later on down the road.

  45. Tina Says:

    oh my God. When did I EVER say that I thought Ted was the son of God? Thank you for proving my point about making assumptions about other people. And just because you see something in print doesnt make it so.. I bet you believe in the Wolf boy in Transylvania too because it was in the Enquirer. Obviously there is no reasoning with you people. All I said was let the man be and if you dont like the show DONT go see it….

  46. Tina Says:

    “And like I said you are completely entitled to your opinion, but please don’t reprimand others for having theirs.”

  47. Tiffany Bridge Says:

    “if you could pull off what he does at 65 at your age ( what are you 20?) then maybe I could listen to your lack of consideration.”

    Let’s keep the conversation civil, please.

  48. Tina Says:

    you know what Tiff. you are right I shouldnt have spouted off like that and I apologize I was just a bit miffed that someone could make a comment like that without having seen the current production.

  49. Sonja Clark Says:

    Well yes Tina, I assume that if it is on Ted’s website that it is true or the webmaster would have deleted or clarified it. I did not mean you personally thinking Ted is God, but those people on his site who post almost everyday, for sure believe he is, it’s sad, really.
    As I said, the show was not too bad, there was some outstanding talent, the guy who played Peter was really good and the guy who played Simon.
    The author of this article posted her opinion of the SHOW and you people turned it into an attack on Ted personally, so if you can voice your opinion than others can too.
    You mean the Wolf boy in Transylvania is not true??? Bummer!

  50. Tiffany Bridge Says:

    The wolf boy in Transylvania is TOTALLY true. We had lunch last week. He says hi.

  51. Tina Says:

    lol sorry to tell you that no he is not real and graphic artist who came up with that images should lose his or her job as it was badly done.. and although I agree that some of Ted’s “fans” are a bit over the top they are harmless.. I happen to know Ted a bit and so you all will have to forvive my wanting to protect his charicter. He really is a lovely man and if you were to ask him about this notion that he thinks himslf the son of God he would laugh, and agree that its a bit scarey. Just dont put the man down for being asked to play a role.

  52. Tina Says:

    PS Simon was amazing as is James Delisco the new Judas.

  53. Don Says:

    I would have figured the wolf boy for being a little more formal. You know, the kind of dude who’d say hellooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo!

  54. Sonja Clark Says:

    Oooohhhh, tell wolfboy hi back!! Wish I had been there, LOL
    It would be fine IF he was just playing a role, but from what I saw and heard while waiting to meet him, he pushes the envelope to the very edge. Taking the character off stage is wrong. The fans who are over the top are only there because he put them there by misrepresenting himself. I heard people talking about how Ted was so concerned about a problem they had. Do these people really think he gives them a second thought after they walk away?? He placates people by telling them what they want to hear, thus making him a phony in my book. Anyway, I wont be seeing the show again, as I saw Corey Glover and was not impressed, so when you are not impressed with the two leads, kind of pointless to pay big bucs for a less than stellar performance.

  55. Soraya Says:

    I don’t want to get involved with this argument, but I do have to make a comment. Sonja, I am guessing you are not a Christian. Ted, blessing people may seem scary to non-believers. As Christians we believe that we can all bless anyone. That is why we pray for each other. Someone who we believe is blessed so much does have the power to bless others. Just because Ted blesses his fans in no way means that he thinks he is God. It only means that he has such a close relationship with God, that God will use him as a tool. I feel that if I go to my Pastor at Church with any burdens I may have, he will bless me. I know it sounds unusual to a non-believer, but it’s normal to us.

  56. Sonja Clark Says:

    Soraya, that is where you are wrong. I am a devout Catholic, and we believe that a personal blessing on behalf of the Father, can only come from someone ordained by Him. Sure, we can all pray for one another and wish each other the blessings of the Father, but we are not ordained to make promises on behalf of the Father or in Ted’s case, the Son. If we were all able to administer rights, why would we need priests and ministers etc.?
    I guess I don’t see Ted as someone special, I see another actor playing a role. I believe he himself has said that he is not religious and does not attend church, so why the facade when he meets with people after a show?

  57. Soraya Says:

    Where was I wrong? Catholic’s are not Christians. Christians do believe that that we can be blessed by anyone who has a close relationship with God.

  58. Tiffany Bridge Says:

    This thread is about a musical, a performer in that musical, and even about the larger issue of ageism in showbusiness. It is not, however, about theology. Please keep the conversation on-topic.

  59. Soraya Says:

    I don’t mean that comment to insulting in any way. A lot of my friends are catholic. I understand what you are saying, and I understand what Catholics beleive. All I’m saying is Christians beleive that anyone blessed, can pass blessings.

  60. Sonja Clark Says:

    SAY WHAT??? Catholics are not Christians?? That is news to me. I bet the Pope would be interested in hearing that? HAhaha
    Anyway, Tiffany, you are right. Let’s go back to the play reviews.

  61. Soraya Says:

    I apologize. That came out sooo wrong.

  62. Tom Bridge Says:

    How about that local sports team?

  63. Tiffany Bridge Says:

    I should add that discussion of the Translyvanian Wolf Boy is completely appropriate for any thread at We Love DC.

  64. Ann Says:

    I think what she is trying to say is that Catholics have different beliefs in praying than Christian denominations do. Most Christian denominations share the same beliefs in praying except for Catholics. Not to say one is right and one is wrong. It’s just that Catholics are a bit stricter (if that’s a good word to use). I would be absolutely thrilled if Ted poured blessings on me.

  65. Tina Says:

    lol well at least I did SOMETHING right lol

  66. Sonja Clark Says:

    If that’s the case Ann, I would be thrilled if Brad Pitt blessed me, but I sure would not count on that to get me into Heaven, LOL

  67. Ann Says:

    I think I see now where the confusion is. Ted does not bless that “one” goes to Heaven. He prays that the Lord be with them to get through difficult times. Just like if someone was to pray for your finances, marriage etc. You could ask for prayer if your foot hurt. I can see now why it looks so weird. Just to set the record straight he in no way is blessing people to Heaven. He is merely praying that the Lord work in there lives.

  68. Claire North Says:

    Thanks Tiffany for not writing anything negative for 24 hours..you were able to do it, unfortunately you were not able to write anything at all and I would like to read something that represents someone in a good light….and no, I do not mean yourself.

    Ted does NOT think himself the Son of God….that is preposterous and actually in the Catholic Church anyone can baptise their child in the name of God, so I guess if someone wants a blessing that will make them feel good, then where is the harm. I visit Ted’s site, initially to look around but stayed because the Ted-Heads are so warm and welcoming. If you are in need of prayer, that is where you go, sometimes you are just in need of a kind word or a supportive shoulder, and again that is where you go. The website is not full of maniacal zealots who worship the ground Ted walks on. They rather appreciate his God-given talent, and discuss further works such as Rasputin, and Pandemonium….we would all love to see those but the audience demand keeps him in this role of JCSS…think on that one…how amazing to be in demand for so long. He is a talented musician and simply said, there are many who having met him, love him. The warmth he exudes and love he so freely gives bond you to him and he feels like an old friend you have known for an eternity…no poor puns here please. I must also let you know that he does have an incredible memory and having met you, WILL recall you again even years later. I could not do that.
    As I have said over and over again, I have seen the role of Jesus played by others and have not been overly impressed, maybe John Farnham would do a good job. No-body has mentioned here however that Andrew Lloyd Weber is going to remake the Rock Opera with someone else, and this should thrill some of you….he is going to do it with a comedien who has a particularly filthy mouth…no kind, gentle man there. I cannot remember his name, blame my liver transplant here, but I know he has been arrested numerous times, and I have watched his behaviour on his own sites so for those who want a nasty Jesus, just wait and you will get your wish soon. In the meantime, let’s just leave Ted alone, you do not like him, so leave it be.

  69. Claire North Says:

    In answer to Sonja, who appears to have some distorted “facts”…and feels free to report them as factual, Ted IS a practicing Christian and does go to Church. He does not perform miracles, if so, I would have asked him to add a couple of zeros to my bank account, and I would be sitting here laughing…..seriously though, the guy has been doing this latest stint for 2 years now and it was NEVER supposed to last this long in the first place but audience demand kept them at it. He loves his friends (not fans) and in defence of them, I have never seen one of them report that they think he is God…or rather, the Son of God. How many musicians actually take time out of their schedule almost every night to talk to people, Ted is one of the few and yet another reason his friends love him. He is infamous for his Ted-hugs, maybe you guys need one…..lol

  70. Sonja Clark Says:

    Hey Claire, maybe you need to watch the interview he did for Religion & Ethics. Out of his own mouth he said the only time he goes to church is for weddings and funerals and admitted he was NOT religious but used the word spiritual instead. But then Ted does change his story often in interviews.
    As for other artists who meet with fans nightly, I can’t think of anyone who does NOT! Meeting with the public is NOT unusual, that’s how artists stay alive in the industry. I guess your activity has been limited or you would know this. You really need to get out more. Check out websites for other artists and there are tons of pictures of them with fans taken after shows.
    Either way…it does not matter, the subject here is supposed to be is he too old to play the part, well the answer in my opinion is yes. He needs to move on to these other projects you all claim he has in the works and give someone else a chance. The only reason he is still in demand is because most people are curious if he can still play the role after doing the movie. I promise you, if he had not done the movie, no one would be flocking to him now. As for a new movie, that is a great idea but I disagree that a foul mouthed Jesus is in order, that is no way what I have been saying. Ted did great in the movie, he represented Jesus in the way that we are taught He was. But now, Ted is just too feeble and his voice is NOT what it used to be, he sounds ragged.
    On to a better subject, Tiffany, I heard the wolfboy met with Edward this afternoon and now he twinkles!!! LOL

  71. Claire North Says:

    Now Sonja, Is there any need really to get personal with me and to make disparaging comments about my “limited activity”….I guess travelling all over the world, and experiencing ballets, opera, musicals and the like is not sufficient for you huh? As to meeting other musicians it is simply not done that they came out later and meet fans….I have never yet met other musicians, nor have I heard of others I know meeting any either. You obviously disagree with me regarding age being an issue here, I do not believe so, but possibly you believe there is a place for ageism???? I hope not. If you will not take my word for it that there are other projects in the works, you can buy his CD of Rasputin, Or Ulysses the Greek, or maybe even check out Pandemonium….don’t believe that is for sale yet but it is my understanding that that is Ted’s personal work, about I think Street Kids. He does a lot with the troubled youth….just wish that there were more like him who put their hard work where their mouths are. We just must agree to disagree, I am not going to change your minds, and no amount of personal insults directed toward me, will change mine. Just while I am pondering your comment that I need to get out more, I infact am a very busy person who LOVES theatre and have seen most everything there is to see, however lately being that I am fighting cancer, have had a liver transplant, and require another one, have an autistic daughter, run a horse rescue, you just might be right. Maybe during one of my upcoming life and death struggles, I should possibly get out to see something more….what would you suggest? So you see I am a fairly good judge of character, and I admire Ted and that is that is that, and on judgement day maybe you can explain to God that you were upset about Ted continuing in this role when he was “far too old for it”…..and we’ll see what the Big Man says…..lol

  72. Sonja Clark Says:

    Hi Claire, I’m sorry to hear of your health issues, and you are right, we are both entitled to our opinion. But you are wrong about other artists, plain and simple. I have met over 50 different actors, musicians etc.(most recently Johnny Depp in Crown Point, In. He did a meet & greet in the town square, advertised it in the local paper) and they all have meet & greets. It’s not unusual. I dont know why you would think it was. Ted Neeley is not the only actor on the planet.
    Either way, if you like the show and the actor, thats great. He’s just not my choice for the role anymore. I am sure God is pleased that His word is still being spread, but I doubt he is happy about false prophets, or people claiming to be able to bless people etc. Either way, just my opinion, so can we talk about the wolfboy now?

  73. Jory Michaels Says:

    Hi! I must say this is good stuff here! I have not laughed so hard since I last read Ted’s guest book! A lot of the people that post over there should seek councelling. I guess God showed up the other day!
    I went to see Ted in this JCS production and was blown away. Not because his voice was rock solid, I could tell that he was getting up there,and not because he “still looked the same.” His increasing baldness kinda takes away from that illusion. I was blown away because of the passion he put behined every note of his solo.
    I would gladly go and see it over and over again, but with someone else interpreting the role. I think it would be fun and it is my favorite play.
    I was in no way encouraged by what I saw, to think that Ted is the son of God or to go find God for that matter, I just like the play.
    I also love all the reviews and comments that have come through during this production, especially this one! Thanks for the laugh, Tiffany, you go girl!

  74. Becky Morris Says:

    Saw the play, met the man. Not impressed with either. Yep, I’m 22.

  75. Tiffany Bridge Says:

    Wow Claire, your life is so full and busy… how DO you find time to keep writing these long comments?

    And Sonja, you’re right, and I HAVE PROOF: Photographic evidence of the meeting between Edward and Wolfboy.

  76. Claire North Says:

    Now again Sonja….why did you have to spoil that nice little “agree to disagree” comment with a “false prophet” scenario….and I do not think that Ted claims to be able to Bless people. Do we not all “Bless people” when we say “God Bless you”……are we not in fact determining that God WILL infact bless others if we say that, and we do say it in comfort….and it does exactly that, comfort a person in need. And you know, I have talked with dying people and reassured them about Heaven, not having been there myself. Is that not presumptious also, and when older people have seen me and thought me a relative, and they are having memory problems, and are dying, Yes I will go along with it, to give them happiness and peace of mind. I do not think there is anything wrong with that, to spread love, and joy, and kindness where ever you go, that is the reason I do not have a problem with anybody blessing anybody….because in the end if it gives them something they were lacking, and gives them inner peace, then that (I believe) is the reason we are here. Just PLEASE leave Ted alone….he is just a really good person….and so many truely do love him because of that.
    So, now I am going to change the subject, but I warn you if you mention Ted again I will have to jump in to his defence…..LOL…I don’t care for any wolfboy, but now Ivan the Impaler…..what a character…..and for those of limited activity…(to use your words Sonja), he is the character that they based Dracula on…..his reign really was one of terror, mahem and good old butchery. And he regularly impaled people while he sat and ate lunch……..spagetti sauce anyone?

  77. Claire North Says:

    Tiffany…I am a fast typist especially when personally insulted, and right now my back, neck, and shoulders are hurting but if I need to ask for some graciousness here, I will have to keep tying until I get it…….Ok….so all of you….hear me out…..oh I think I have said every thing I am going to say unless you keep nit-picking…….and then tomorrow is yet another day…this is normally my unwind time, as my daughter is in bed….but you are correct, I am facing and have faced many hurdles but God does not want me right now…..I nearly died once….it is kinda funny but I lost my eyesight and my ability to talk….yeah yeah, but could think and hear, and everything was black in front of me….no light at the end of any tunnel so my friend told me later that I was going in the other direction…..if that is the case, we can continue the arguement down there?????huh?????

  78. Sonja Clark Says:

    Claire, why wouldn’t Ted be the topic of discussion? This is a review of the show. He’s a public figure, duh? Defend away, you can’t change the fact that he’s in his 60’s, his voice is ragged and he’s quite feeble on the stage. Facts are facts.
    Tiff, great shot of Edward & Wolfboy, LOL

    And Claire, you can send me a postcard from”down there” I’m going the other way.

  79. SORAYA Says:

    Sonja’s comment- , “I am sure God is pleased that His word is still being spread, but I doubt he is happy about false prophets”

    Did I miss something here? When did he claim to be a prophet? What did he claim to prophesize? Did you have an article to back up this new claim? I think you have just reached a new low of just making things up to try to prove a point.

  80. Sonja Clark Says:

    As I said before, we can disagree on how Mr. Neeley conducts his life off stage. We see his actions through different eyes, no harm no foul. I do know that I prefer to be around people who are more sincere in their actions with others. I have met the man, and I’m sorry, I did not buy his act, seemed he tried too hard to be nice, so much so that it appeared fake. Sorry, but that’s the way I feel. We are all entitled to our opinions. Now, as for the play, it is good enough but I like more action for my buck. I’ll take Rent anytime over Superstar, or Wicked for that matter. Tiffany, have you seen either of these?

  81. Claire North Says:

    Sonja, you couldn’t let go…you are like a dog with a bone that just won’t give it up…..I DO realise he is a public figure and like the rest of us, he IS getting older…..I do not think that his voice is ragged and he is feeble on stage….and this is not a fact….it is a subjective personal opinion. Just please leave him be…you have all had your fun…yes you have attacked someone verbally who has not had an opportunity to defend himself, and you know, that cruelty in humour is the lowest form of wit. I am particularly happy for you that you seem quite confident you will be travelling upwards at the end of your days….I do not think that any religion or Church would preach unkindness to others as a way to get into Heaven….rather grace, humility, and kindness are the way to go. Have you ever heard the saying “Live and Let LIve”….it just might apply here…so why don’t we put some of this kinetic energy that is being wasted running down a kind soul to some actual use and maybe talk about a way to stop child abuse, women battering and murder, child porn and a whole range of other subjects that actually need our energy?

  82. Sonja Clark Says:

    Claire, maybe you are the one who should let it go. This is not a session of running down your “kind soul”, it’s a review of the show and the stars of it. This is not unkindness, it’s a review, you don’t seem to get that. I personally don’t care what Ted inflicts on others, as long as he doesn’t try to convince me that he has the authority to preach. Either way, enjoy yourself with him, and I will stick with the teachings of the first Christian Church. Maybe you, being the expert can give us a review of the other works of Mr. Neeley, Rasputin sounds like it may be a little more age approperiate.

  83. Claire North Says:

    No Sonja,

    a review is definately not what it is…can someone review the show watching a television commercial and then taking pot shots at the age of the cast. No, let’s be honest here, it is an attack on a human being. I can understand if you do not like the show, nor Ted, nor the cast, nor the music. That said, I do and many more like me do…and you wonder why I cannot “let it go”…I’ll tell you why, because it is an underhanded illinformed personal opinion…and if a review were in order, then you would not be insulting those who visit his guest book and you would not insult him….at least if you were a good writer. So you see you brought it to a low by insinuating negative personal things. Honestly think for a moment, how would you feel if I attacked and attacked and attacked someone who meant something to you? Would you not jump to their defence? I do not dislike you nor am judging you, but I try hard to live a good Christian life, and based upon the teachings of the Bible, say or do not harm to others. So, I would ask you just to stop the nastiness regarding Ted and his fans. That’s all. Thanks Tiffany for not continuing this discussion…you made your point, and to your credit, did not go on and on about it. Thank you.

  84. Lynn Rodriguez Says:

    WHAT A ROTTEN THING TO SAY! It is easy for you to be critical and judgemental because of your youth, ignorance and lack of finess which can only develop as you age. JCSS would not be worth seeing if Ted did not play the role. I will be seeing it for the 3ed time in two years on March 13th. I have traveled three times to see it from Florida to North Carolina, and to Georgia and again I will be traveling to see it on 13 March from Florida. I have had to save up my money and do without but I find seeing it live worth it. I met Ted once and I know God walks with him and has influenced him in this role. Anyone that meets him (believer and non believer) would be able to see this. He is not God, nor does he claim to be. I am not a JCSS groupe, just a fan that learns more about her beloved savior from the role that Ted plays. Thank you Ted for doing what you do, don’t let negative people like this take away the good that you give to the world.

  85. Claire North Says:

    Just a point of interest to me Sonja….or should I say Tiffany?????? Why don’t you use one name or the other…..you are cheeky!!!!!lol

  86. Tiffany Bridge Says:

    What a silly and baseless accusation. I’m an editorial coordinator here. I have an account that verifies my identity. I don’t need to stoop to silly sock-puppet tricks, and you don’t need to stoop to throwing that kind of accusation around without evidence.

    I remind all of you, but especially you, Claire, about the We Love DC Comment Policy. Please do not continue to violate it by insulting WLDC staff or other commenters. If you’re only interested in insulting people who disagree with you, you can take that kind of behavior right back to the FriendsofTedNeeley group or wherever it is that you come from.

  87. Sonja Clark Says:

    Lynn, are you saying that anyone who does not like Superstar or Ted Neeley is ignorant, or younger people are ignorant? Do people not have the right to dislike it as much as you have the right to like it? Seems pretty one sided to me.
    Claire, I am sure that this is not the first time, as a matter of fact, I am sure that many times a bad review of the show has been printed, why are you so adament about proving here what a super guy Ted Neeley is? I do have one question though, if Ted is not worried about the age factor and all you “tedheads” think it’s so grand that he is still playing the role, why does he have a 15 year old picture on his opening page of his website? Why not something more currant? Because it is very misleading, you go to a show thinking you are going to see the man in this picture and what you get is far from it.
    That being said, I want to thank you for comparing me to Tiffany, I only wish I had her talent for writing and her sense of humor! She appears to call it as she sees it.
    So, anyone reading this who has not seen the show needs to see it and be their own judge. They have read both sides of the coin.
    Phrase for the day “There is no fool like an old fool”

  88. Claire North Says:

    Or maybe “Thou shalt not bear false witness”…….

  89. Sue P Says:

    Open (your) mouth, insert foot

  90. Tom Bridge Says:

    Would this be a good tactical use of “OH SNAP!” ? Or would that be too young and hip for the Over-50-and-love-my-Jesus-Wrinkly-and-With-a-Walker crowd?

  91. Tina Says:

    Im not over 50 but I do respect my elders.. and the golden rule.

  92. Claire North Says:

    Oh excuse me,
    but I was informed this was only a review of the show and cast and NOT an attack on a person or person(s).
    Maybe you should get together and decide what it is that you are actually doing because you are here, there, and everywhere. One minute it is a review, the next, a comment on inequality of women in the entertainment industry which I and no doubt everyone, would agree with you there, it is definately alive and kicking, the next thing it is ageism, again alive and apparently doing well right here, and the next thing, it is an attack on fans of Ted, with derogatory comments insinuating that because they enjoy his shows and post on his site, they are in need of counselling….my thought is, that maybe some of you, are in dire need of some etiquette training. As I have said over and over and over again, I can understand if you do not like Ted, the cast, the music, the show, the musicians, the composer, the set, the fans, the history, the movie….but leave those alone who do. Tom, I want to just say, that no I am not 50, and to make derogatory comments about those over 50 being wrinkled and in need of walking assistance, insults those who are, including your own mother and father….would they enjoy a comment like that which includes them….as no doubt they are that age or older, or very possibly, age does bring you wisdom, and they simply understand it is merely your ignorance and inconsideration. I hope when you get to 50 and over, you are the recipient of kindness and understanding and compassion if you need it. I don’t dislike you, nor anyone here, that goes against the grain, but I do respect my elders, and those who have made the world a little bit nicer for being here….to me and many others, that includes Ted. I would so LOVE it if you could ever get to meet him….you would maybe understand us a little better. Until then, God Bless you and yours and everyone else who has contributed to this discussion….it has been interesting to say the least, and I think with so much energy here, we could talk about something that really needs work….like abuse of kids, the economy and what we are EACH going to do to help it get a little better. That is my challenge to you.

  93. Roz Says:

    Might I just mention that the Dracula character was based on Vlad The Impaler, not Ivan The Impaler. Maybe someone got Ivan The Terrible mixed up with Prince Vlad… two different historical figures, but both had major mental issues. Unless Vlad’s middle name was Ivan? LOL!

  94. Soraya Says:

    I have seen a few different actors play Jesus in JCS. None come close to Ted. So yes Tom I guess I do love my Jesus that way. By the way, I’m 28 years old.

  95. Sonja Clark Says:

    Ya know Claire, I let you have the last word, I gave it 24 hours before I posted, thinking you would be happy with the last word, but I can see YOU are the one who keeps stirring the pot. I have tried to change the subject as others have, and you keep bringing it back to Ted. Me thinks thou dost protest too much. And Sue P,if anyone has their foot in their mouth, it’s Claire. Yes, I have been to Neeleyontheroad.com and frankly it’s just too “preachy” for me. I like to get my sermons from those more qualified, but to each his own. As for the friends of ted neeley, I have no clue what that is but I DO know I want no part of it, Ted’s guestbook is just fun to read and laugh at.

  96. Deppaholic Says:

    Okay……
    Roz you are right about Vlad the Impailer. I have seen JCSS movie many times, and love it, love the music and all the actors, singers and dancers. I was fortunate enough to see this production last month and my opinion is that Ted brings so much passion to this role whatever age he may be this year….after all, its just a number, right? I had the great pleasure of meeting Mr. Neeley after the show and found him to be very genuine and not GODLIKE at all. He did not fly up through the theatre to meet us. My husband is a 6th degree black belt in both Karate and Hapkido and he was showing Ted a few moves. Later that evening my husband told me he was impressed with how strong TN was, because he did show TN how to do a few holds. I sat in the theatre and could see TN doing pushups backstage before he went on. I could see through this mesh screen, and I lost count of how many he did, which were quite a few, Please dont let age fool you, we have Bruce Lees hapkido instructor coming to our studio once a month and he is in his 70s and can whip our best black belts around like wet noodles…FYI……You may or may not like the show, thats what is great about our country, free speech. We are all entitled to it. I am not IN LOVE with TN, nor do I think he is GOD, but I do love the fact that God chooses to continues to bless him and use him in bringing the gospel to the masses. God is still in control, and if He didnt want TN doing this, it would not be done. Thank you very much, this has been an interesting read…..I will go see TN perform again, because he brought Jesus to life for me on film, and I admire him for doing so…..I agree with others that there are many who think stars/athletes bleed a different color, but they do not…I came away from meeting with TN feeling he is very genuine and just one of those people who cares for his fellow human beings. It is very sad some people obviously just dont get it!!! God is the potter, TN is his clay :) Love and peace to all :)

  97. Joseph J. Finn Says:

    Wait, I thought everyone agreed that Carl Anderson was the star of JCS. I mean, the story is all about how Judas was manipulated (almost cruelly, one may so) into fulfilling both his and Jesus’ destiny, right?

  98. Tina Says:

    The story is about the last week of the life of Christ. It was written in such a way as to show the human side of Christ and his desiples from Jusdas’ point of view. Quite controversial for its time.

  99. Claire North Says:

    Sonja,

    You are quite correct….we left it for 24 hours and I like you thought it over…that in our own ways we would agree to disagree but then I get Tom’s backhanded comment in my email and so if you want to lay the continuation of this conversation at anybody’s door….then lay it at his….because he was obviously not satisfied at leaving things be….he did the stirring of the cauldron not I…check the times displayed above the comments.
    And to everyone…yep my bad…The historical character was Big Bad Vlad NOT as I said….Ivan….oooppps. So there we have it.
    Joseph….the story is interesting and I for my part sympathise with Judas because he had to do what he had to do, and maybe he was the only one strong enough to carry through Jesus’s wishes….I think the two characters myself, have equally demanding roles in this production, but yes, it does centre around the last 7 days of the life of Christ as shown through the eyes of Judas.
    Makes you wonder what you would have done if you had been there and part of the crowd when he was tortured and crucified????

  100. Art Drauglis Says:

    I am feeling the need to make an indignant, pointless comment. Instead I will say that actors need to move through the various roles in a given script, leaving the younger ones to younger actors and likewise after maturing.

  101. Dee Says:

    As I read the posts I’m torn between laughing and crying. All Tiffany did was say she saw an ad, commented that Ted was ‘geriatric’ and wondered why he was still playing the part. Even as a former ‘Ted Head’ I have to admit…Ted IS old. Even TED knows he is old, at least he did the last time I spoke to him. The more you guys argue how he ‘has to’ play Jesus, the less believable it seems to be. Ted is an ACTOR, period end of story. He is not acting on behalf of God, again at least he wasn’t as of the last time we spoke. Granted that was ages ago and he may have changed his mind since then. I will agree that Ted is, in MY mind anyway, still awesome in the ‘part’ of Jesus. However, it scares me when I see him being portrayed as more than he is. He used to teasingly sing, “I’m a man…I’m just a man…” did that change somehow? When I was a Ted Head, and yes, I was considered pretty much ‘queen’ of them, at least on the internet… Ted was just … Ted. Okay, maybe I lusted after him a bit back then (in my heart of course and maybe a little more than ‘a bit’, and enjoyed the wicked twinkle in his eyes when flirting, and just being around him made my head spin, but I knew as did all my other TedHead friends, that Ted was playing a role. One he is very, very good at. I met Ted when I was going through some major issues in my life and he was very sweet to me. And the fact that I had been carrying a crush of enormous proportions since first seeing the movie at age of 18, getting to meet and talk to him was … OMG!!! He is charming and charismatic and no one can take that away from him. He knows what to say and has such a great memory of people it’s hard not to feel special. So,as I said in an earlier post, wouldn’t it be better just to agree to disagree? Some like Ted as Jesus, some don’t…some people say tomAto..some say tomato… Sometimes you feel like a nut..sometimes you don’t…Please though, for the sake of every fan of Ted, or used to be fans, stop trying to make him into something he is not. In my opinion, it does make us all look like religious nuts. Sorry if this sounds harsh, but if I’m going to be thought of as crazy, I’d rather it be by my own actions/words and not for having been a fan of a great play.

  102. Lianne Says:

    I want to meet the Transylvanian Wolf Boy. Tiffany, do you have an email address by chance? I hear he’s quite the dinner date — always goes out for steak.

  103. Sonja Clark Says:

    Hi Dee, sounds like you may be the only one who has posted here who has seen a glimpse of the REAL Ted. It sounds like at one time you two were really close. Thank you for posting and letting everyone here know that not all his fans are so caught up in what they WANT him to be that they fail to see what and who he is really is, just a man, an actor, doing what he is getting paid to do. Maybe all his zealots will take your word for it, then maybe not.
    And it’s nice to know that he himself is aware of his short comings, but he really needs to be just more of himself when meeting with people, step out of the role and be real. The REAL Ted sounds pretty cool.

  104. Allyson Says:

    The Real Ted IS cool. I’ve only known him a few years. I am not caught up in what I want him to be and he will be the first to tell you that he is playing a role. What I have enjoyed about him is his kindness. I have never met anyone in theater quite like him. I love this show. I’ve seen others play the part very well. There is just something about Ted that when he acts this role he transforms it and the music and his voice can just carry you away. Part of it is nostalgia. But mostly he knows how to put a song across and connect with the audience on a level not often seen. For me anyway…

  105. Joe Says:

    Have you even seen the show? Another mindless, irrelevant blogger. Is this YOUR big accomplishment?

  106. Ann Stickford Says:

    Hi Tiffany — I just happened to come onto your
    website, and sorry to see it has become a war of
    words just like the other ones some of these people write on, including, NOTR, Ted’s how site-
    I just wanted to say everyone sees things their own way when seeing a play, etc. – as for
    Jesus Christ, Superstar, – Ted was in his late 20’s when on Broadway, but was 30 or 31 when he did the movie — I have known Ted for almost 35 years and we are just 10 months different in age (he’s older! HA!)
    I, too, have seen JCS done with several different
    actors playing Jesus, and I feel Ted protrays the
    way I grew up knowing my teachings of Jesus the best, but that is jmo —
    Will continue to read your site — interesting!
    Ann